Continuing my commentary on a student’s exchange with ChatGPT, this sequence on “intent-to-execution” is particularly interesting.

Pat: I’m looking at how the brain processes the signals (intent) for motion. There is a theory that “thinking”, which involves the pre-frontal cortex, interrupts the signal to the motor-system, which results in clumsy or less effective swings/motion. The theory suggests that you want to shut down the pre-frontal cortex when swinging the club to get into a flow, commonly referred to as the zone. Do you see much support for this theory?
ChatGPT: Short answer: yes, there is meaningful support for the idea – the effect people observe (thinking hurts fluid motion; “flow” helps it) is real.
Golf is especially vulnerable to this problem because:
It’s self-paced
High precision
High consequence
Plenty of time to think
Elite golfers:
Use very simple swing cues
Focus on Tempo, Target, Rhythm
Avoid internal mechanical thoughts during execution
Common effective cues:
“Smooth”
“Finish”
“Swing to the target”
“Brush the grass”
These bypass PFC-heavy processing.
My comment: As with any mental game tip (and we can categorise all ChatGPT’s advice as falling into this category) after a while the ‘effective cues’ become less effective and eventually become one more thing to think about. I’ve heard this from the tour players I’ve worked with as well as the committed amateur player.
Let’s use Tempo as an example to explore this. When my students train the centuries-old practices to develop natural movement abilities and which form part of my methodology, the body itself takes on certain qualities such as that of ‘relaxed readiness’ or ‘moving from the centre’ or finding ‘true balance’.
As a result, the tempo, rhythm and timing of the golf swing takes care of itself in a very natural, non-directive way. This has even been remarked upon by golfers who’ve played and taught the game for over 50 years. Yet when golfers ‘think about tempo’ or have it as a mental cue before the swing or putt, especially if that thought is particularly strong, it interrupts the signal to the motor system resulting in a shot which is invariably out-of-sync. The more the golfer tries to correct this using the same mind-led cues, the more frustrated they become as the further away they get from swinging anywhere near their natural tempo.
In my book, Connected Golf; Bridging the Gap Between Practice and Performance, I posit an imaginary performance scale with ‘Control-freak Mind’ at one end and ‘Team Mind-Body’ at the other. When golfers use the moments over the ball to bring awareness to the body instead of thinking through technique, they enter a more connected state where mind and body work together and the swing feels effortless.
Conversely, when preparation time is used in thinking (and I don’t mean visualising which is less verbal and more to do with forming images in the mind of your intended outcome) any awareness or connection to the body is swallowed up by analysis. In its worst case scenario, this can lead to an overuse of the pre-frontal cortex / ‘Control-freak Mind’ and an inability to move the body freely.
If the ‘common effective swing cues’ outlined by ChatGPT actually helped, golf wouldn’t be, as Arnold Palmer once said “…a game that’s deceptively simple and endlessly complicated” and players would swing the club according to the idea they have of the shot in their mind. But we all know it doesn’t work like that. The more the mind gets involved, the less able the player is to execute the shot and the suggestion that elite players somehow ‘avoid internal mechanical thoughts during execution’ while it may be something to aspire towards, is only part of the solution and something that needs to be worked on.
The quieter the mind the more fluid the motion, but as the quiet mind is not our current default state (you’ll know the truth of this if you’ve ever witnessed the restlessness of your own mind as it flits from one thing to another keeping it interested, fretful or amused) quietude and concentration need to be trained.
Unfortunately, for many people this process and the ensuing emptiness that’s sometimes felt can be unbearable or at the very least boring, so the tendency is to revert to the endless round of thinking and the incessant inner dialogue. It has even been noted that a golfer may start their swing with one simple cue in mind but by the time they are coming down from the top, another thought, idea or technical tip has already replaced it.
In the digital age, this struggle for internal quietude will reach a crisis point with one of two results; either we make a prolonged and concerted effort towards inner silence and enjoy a journey into higher states of consciousness (the zone or flow being the most commonly experienced but so often misunderstood) or we rely on big data to give us even more information to keep us forever tied to the mental level of experience.
As I have written about elsewhere, and many hundreds of golfers have confirmed, those perfect shots, the flow shots when everything comes together just right and we play in a way that’s beyond our normal capabilities points humanity towards levels above and beyond the thinking mind and towards a new adventure that we are only at the beginning of. These supra-mental states are something AI can never understand but they are available to all players who are willing to spend time each day learning to be quiet.
Please reach out for a 30 min exploratory call if this is something you’d like to discuss.